Minify
Update: online live demo running on a Raspberry Pi 2.
Update: command-line-interface executable minify
provided for tooling.
Minify is a minifier package written in Go. It has build-in HTML5, CSS3, JS, JSON, SVG and XML minifiers and provides an interface to implement any minifier. Minification is the process of removing bytes from a file (such as whitespace) without changing its output and therefore speeding up transmission over the internet. The implemented minifiers are high performance and streaming (which implies O(n)).
It associates minification functions with mime types, allowing embedded resources (like CSS or JS in HTML files) to be minified too. The user can add any mime-based implementation. Users can also implement a mime type using an external command (like the ClosureCompiler, UglifyCSS, ...). It is possible to pass parameters through the mimetype to specify the charset for example.
Bottleneck for minification is mainly io and can be significantly sped up by having the file loaded into memory and providing a Bytes() []byte
function like bytes.Buffer
does.
See the Wiki for a roadmap of what is planned for the future.
Table of Contents
Prologue
Minifiers or bindings to minifiers exist in almost all programming languages. Some implementations are merely using several regular-expressions to trim whitespace and comments (even though regex for parsing HTML/XML is ill-advised, for a good read see Regular Expressions: Now You Have Two Problems). Some implementations are much more profound, such as the YUI Compressor, Google Closure Compiler for JS and the HTML Compressor.
These industry-grade minifiers are written in Java and are generally slow too. Futhermore, these tools provide a large number of configurations which is often confusing or not needed. Regular-expression based minifiers are slow anyways because they often use multiple regular-expressions, each of which parses the complete document. While regular-expressions are overkill (or ill-advised) for parsing HTML/CSS/JS documents, parsing it a number of times is certainly not speeding things up. Other implementations are often written in uncompiled languages such as JS, which is great for bindings with Grunt for example, but catastrophic for the minification speed of large files or projects with many files.
Additionally many of these minifier either do not follow the specifications or drag a lot of legacy code around. When you are still trying to support IE6 I don't suppose you are squeezing out every bit of performance out of your web application. Supporting old mistakes or work-arounds is not a fairly long-term vision.
However, implementing an HTML minifier is the bare minimum. HTML documents can contain embedded resources such as CSS, JS and SVG file formats. Thus for increased minification of HTML, other file format minifiers must be present too. A minifier should really handle a number of mediatypes to be successful.
This minifier proves to be that fast, zero-configurable, modern, extensive minifier which stream-minifies files and can minify them concurrently.
Comparison
HTML (with JS and CSS) minification typically runs at about 30MB/s ~= 100GB/h, depending on the composition of the file.
Website |
Original |
Minified |
Ratio |
Time* |
Amazon |
463kB |
414kB |
89% |
13ms |
BBC |
113kB |
96kB |
85% |
4ms |
StackOverflow |
201kB |
182kB |
91% |
7ms |
Wikipedia |
435kB |
410kB |
94%** |
14ms |
*These times are measured on my home computer which is an average development computer. The duration varies a lot but it's important to see it's in the 10ms range! The benchmark uses all the minifiers and excludes reading from and writing to the file from the measurement.
**Is already somewhat minified, so this doesn't reflect the full potential of this minifier.
HTML Compressor performs worse in output size (for HTML and CSS) and speed; it is a magnitude slower. Its whitespace removal is not precise or the user must provide the tags around which can be trimmed. According to HTML Compressor, it produces smaller files than a couple of other libraries. With HTML and CSS minification this package is better, but JS minification it is still too basic.
Alternatives
An alternative library written in Go is https://github.com/dchest/htmlmin. It is simpler (less bugs but not handling edge-cases) but slower. Also https://github.com/omeid/jsmin contains a port of JSMin, just like this JS minifier, but is slower.
Other alternatives are bindings for existing minifiers written in other languages. These are inevitably more robust and tested but will often be slower. For example, Java-based minifiers incur overhead of starting up the JVM.
HTML
The HTML5 minifier uses these minifications:
- strip unnecessary whitespace and otherwise collapse it to one space
- strip superfluous quotes, or uses single/double quotes whichever requires fewer escapes
- strip default attribute values and attribute boolean values
- strip some empty attributes
- strip unrequired tags (
html
, head
, body
, ...)
- strip unrequired end tags (
tr
, td
, li
, ... and often p
)
- strip default protocols (
http:
, https:
and javascript:
)
- strip comments (except conditional comments)
- shorten
doctype
and meta
charset
- lowercase tags, attributes and some values to enhance gzip compression
After recent benchmarking and profiling it became really fast and minifies pages in the 10ms range, making it viable for on-the-fly minification.
However, be careful when doing on-the-fly minification. Minification typically trims off 10% and does this at worst around about 20MB/s. This means users have to download slower than 2MB/s to make on-the-fly minification worthwhile. This may or may not apply in your situation. Rather use caching!
Beware
Make sure your HTML doesn't depend on whitespace between block
elements that have been changed to inline
or inline-block
elements using CSS. Your layout should not depend on those whitespaces as the minifier will remove them. An example is a menu consisting of multiple <li>
that have display:inline-block
applied and have whitespace in between them. It is bad practise to rely on whitespace for element positioning anyways!
CSS
Minification typically runs at about 20MB/s ~= 70GB/h.
Library |
Original |
Minified |
Ratio |
Time* |
Bootstrap |
134kB |
111kB |
83% |
6ms |
Gumby |
182kB |
167kB |
91% |
9ms |
*The benchmark excludes the time reading from and writing to a file from the measurement.
The CSS minifier will only use safe minifications:
- remove comments and unnecessary whitespace
- remove trailing semicolons
- optimize
margin
, padding
and border-width
number of sides
- shorten numbers by removing unnecessary
+
and zeros and rewriting with/without exponent
- remove dimension and percentage for zero values
- remove quotes for URLs
- remove quotes for font families and make lowercase
- rewrite hex colors to/from color names, or to 3 digit hex
- rewrite
rgb(
, rgba(
, hsl(
and hsla(
colors to hex or name
- replace
normal
and bold
by numbers for font-weight
and font
- replace
none
→ 0
for border
, background
and outline
- lowercase all identifiers except classes, IDs and URLs to enhance gzip compression
- shorten MS alpha function
- rewrite data URIs with base64 or ASCII whichever is shorter
- calls minifier for data URI mediatypes, thus you can compress embedded SVG files if you have that minifier attached
It does purposely not use the following techniques:
- (partially) merge rulesets
- (partially) split rulesets
- collapse multiple declarations when main declaration is defined within a ruleset (don't put
font-weight
within an already existing font
, too complex)
- remove overwritten properties in ruleset (this not always overwrites it, for example with
!important
)
- rewrite properties into one ruleset if possible (like
margin-top
, margin-right
, margin-bottom
and margin-left
→ margin
)
- put nested ID selector at the front (
body > div#elem p
→ #elem p
)
- rewrite attribute selectors for IDs and classes (
div[id=a]
→ div#a
)
- put space after pseudo-selectors (IE6 is old, move on!)
It's great that so many other tools make comparison tables: CSS Minifier Comparison, CSS minifiers comparison and CleanCSS tests. From the last link, this CSS minifier is almost without doubt the fastest and has near-perfect minification rates. It falls short with the purposely not implemented and often unsafe techniques, so that's fine.
JS
The JS minifier is pretty basic. It removes comments, whitespace and line breaks whenever it can. It follows the rules by JSMin but additionally fixes the error in the 'caution' section.
Minification typically runs at about 45MB/s ~= 160GB/h.
Library |
Original |
Minified |
Ratio |
Time* |
ACE |
616kB |
433kB |
70% |
13ms |
jQuery |
242kB |
130kB |
54% |
5ms |
jQuery UI |
459kB |
300kB |
65% |
11ms |
Moment |
97kB |
51kB |
52% |
2ms |
*The benchmark excludes the time reading from and writing to a file from the measurement.
TODO:
- shorten local variables / function parameters names
- precise semicolon and newline omission
JSON
Minification typically runs at about 75MB/s ~= 270GB/h. It shaves off about 15% of filesize for common indented JSON such as generated by JSON Generator.
The JSON minifier only removes whitespace, which is the only thing that can be left out.
SVG
The SVG minifier uses these minifications:
- trim and collapse whitespace between all tags
- strip comments,
doctype
, XML prelude, metadata
- strip SVG version
- strip CDATA sections wherever possible
- collapse tags with no content to a void tag
- collapse empty container tags (
g
, svg
, ...)
- minify style tag and attributes with the CSS minifier
- minify colors
- shorten lengths and numbers and remove default
px
unit
- shorten the
path
data m
attribute
TODO:
- convert
rect
, line
, polygon
, polyline
to path
- convert attributes to style attribute whenever shorter
- use relative instead of absolute positions for path data (need bytes2float)
- merge path data? (same style and no intersection -- the latter is difficult)
XML
Minification typically runs at about 50MB/s ~= 180GB/h.
The XML minifier uses these minifications:
- strip unnecessary whitespace and otherwise collapse it to one space
- strip comments
- collapse tags with no content to a void tag
- strip CDATA sections wherever possible
Installation
Run the following command
go get github.com/tdewolff/minify
or add the following imports and run the project with go get
import (
"github.com/tdewolff/minify"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify/css"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify/html"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify/js"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify/json"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify/svg"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify/xml"
)
Usage
New
Retrieve a minifier struct which holds a map of mediatype → minifier functions.
m := minify.New()
The following loads all provided minifiers.
m := minify.New()
m.AddFunc("text/css", css.Minify)
m.AddFunc("text/html", html.Minify)
m.AddFunc("text/javascript", js.Minify)
m.AddFunc("image/svg+xml", svg.Minify)
m.AddFuncRegexp(regexp.MustCompile("[/+]json$"), json.Minify)
m.AddFuncRegexp(regexp.MustCompile("[/+]xml$"), xml.Minify)
From reader
Minify from an io.Reader
to an io.Writer
for a specific mediatype.
if err := m.Minify(mediatype, w, r); err != nil {
log.Fatal("Minify:", err)
}
Minify HTML, CSS or JS directly from an io.Reader
to an io.Writer
. The passed mediatype is not required for these functions, but are filled out for clarity.
if err := css.Minify(m, "text/css", w, r); err != nil {
log.Fatal("css.Minify:", err)
}
if err := html.Minify(m, "text/html", w, r); err != nil {
log.Fatal("html.Minify:", err)
}
if err := js.Minify(m, "text/javascript", w, r); err != nil {
log.Fatal("js.Minify:", err)
}
if err := json.Minify(m, "application/json", w, r); err != nil {
log.Fatal("json.Minify:", err)
}
if err := svg.Minify(m, "image/svg+xml", w, r); err != nil {
log.Fatal("svg.Minify:", err)
}
if err := xml.Minify(m, "text/xml", w, r); err != nil {
log.Fatal("xml.Minify:", err)
}
From bytes
Minify from and to a []byte
for a specific mediatype.
b, err = minify.Bytes(m, mediatype, b)
if err != nil {
log.Fatal("minify.Bytes:", err)
}
From string
Minify from and to a string
for a specific mediatype.
s, err = minify.String(m, mediatype, s)
if err != nil {
log.Fatal("minify.String:", err)
}
Custom minifier
Add a function for a specific mediatype.
m.AddFunc(mediatype, func(m minify.Minifier, mediatype string, w io.Writer, r io.Reader) error {
// ...
return nil
})
Add a command cmd
with arguments args
for a specific mediatype.
m.AddCmd(mediatype, exec.Command(cmd, args...))
Mediatypes can contain parameters (type/subtype; key1=val2; key2=val2
). Minifiers can also be added using a regular expression. For example a minifier with image/.*
will match any image mime.
Mediatypes such as text/plain; charset=UTF-8
will be processed by text/plain
or any regexp it matches. The mediatype string is passed to the minifier function which can retrieve the parameters using the standard library mime.ParseMediaType
.
Examples
Basic example that minifies from stdin to stdout and loads the default HTML, CSS and JS minifiers. Optionally, one can enable java -jar build/compiler.jar
to run for JS (for example the ClosureCompiler). Note that reading the file into a buffer first and writing to a pre-allocated buffer would be faster (but would disable streaming).
package main
import (
"log"
"os"
"os/exec"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify/css"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify/html"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify/js"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify/json"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify/svg"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify/xml"
)
func main() {
m := minify.New()
m.AddFunc("text/css", css.Minify)
m.AddFunc("text/html", html.Minify)
m.AddFunc("text/javascript", js.Minify)
m.AddFunc("image/svg+xml", svg.Minify)
m.AddFuncRegexp(regexp.MustCompile("[/+]json$"), json.Minify)
m.AddFuncRegexp(regexp.MustCompile("[/+]xml$"), xml.Minify)
// Or use the following for better minification of JS but lower speed:
// m.AddCmd("text/javascript", exec.Command("java", "-jar", "build/compiler.jar"))
if err := m.Minify("text/html", os.Stdout, os.Stdin); err != nil {
log.Fatal("Minify:", err)
}
}
Custom minifier showing an example that implements the minifier function interface. Within a custom minifier, it is possible to call any minifier function (through m minify.Minifier
) recursively when dealing with embedded resources.
package main
import (
"bufio"
"fmt"
"io"
"log"
"strings"
"github.com/tdewolff/minify"
)
// Outputs "Becausemycoffeewastoocold,Iheateditinthemicrowave."
func main() {
m := minify.New()
// remove newline and space bytes
m.AddFunc("text/plain", func(m minify.Minifier, mediatype string, w io.Writer, r io.Reader) error {
rb := bufio.NewReader(r)
for {
line, err := rb.ReadString('\n')
if err != nil && err != io.EOF {
return err
}
if _, errws := io.WriteString(w, strings.Replace(line, " ", "", -1)); errws != nil {
return errws
}
if err == io.EOF {
break
}
}
return nil
})
out, err := minify.String(m, "text/plain", "Because my coffee was too cold, I heated it in the microwave.")
if err != nil {
log.Fatal("Minify:", err)
}
fmt.Println(out)
}
License
Released under the MIT license.